Dice-method for the players' order in a room

18 replies [Last post]
rbaleksandar
rbaleksandar's picture
User offline. Last seen 10 years 14 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-01-09
Posts: 685

Hi, guys. Smile

Just read something that made me wonder why it's made in such a way. It's about filling the list with teams when creating a game. If you put three teams A,B and C in the order [A->B->C], each and every game will start with team A as the first team to kick some but. Here's the idea: add a button with exactly the same function as the dice-button in the team-settings where you can choose a random team/name. So the creator of the room will fill the list as follows - A,B,C (so that team A starts in the first round). Next game she/he can press this button and change the order randomly (dice-method) so that we get now for example C,A,B or B,C,A etc. etc. This would make it quicker to start the next game without loosing precious time to wonder who was first in the previous N games and how should the order be in the game that follows.

Greetings!

HTML = How To Meet the Ladies

Here is my Unofficial Manual for HW. Hope you like it. Wink Smiley Still working on it. Don't worry. Will get it finished...Sometime in the future. Big Grin

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

Well, guess we can discuss this now here. :P
My suggestion is just to make this the default! Always scramble the team order!

If we're talking about pure-hardcore-competition mode, probably used in tournaments, the option "don't scramble turns order" can be added as a mode since those kind of games are probably around only 0.000001% of all the rounds played.

Thomas
Thomas's picture
User offline. Last seen 11 years 44 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-02-06
Posts: 233

i wouldnt set it as default, were doing a gamecheme right now where the 1st, second and third player always has to play the same role (first has to catch the prisoner with many builders, second has to get him out, third has to wait till he can get out Wink Smiley all the way till armageddon comes and hes out or not...

I would suggest a button for that, wouldnt be too hard

please add your xfire accountname here:
http://www.hedgewars.org/node/1977

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

Thomas allegedly wrote:

i wouldnt set it as default, were doing a gamecheme right now where the 1st, second and third player always has to play the same role (first has to catch the prisoner with many builders, second has to get him out, third has to wait till he can get out Wink Smiley all the way till armageddon comes and hes out or not...

I would suggest a button for that, wouldnt be too hard

What about everyone that doesn't ever realize this happens? I didn't for a while and i bet most people never realized that and kept getting their butts kicked by the same smartass (that do no share that the game works like that) over and over again on the 1st round.
Plus if you add a dice, people might click it more than once, and cause "ragers" and "rage quitters" to keep placing their teams back into the game and out.
Your games are only other 0.000001% or less Thomas. So that would be 0.000002% of games that use that option, would it justify being a button? What you do even sounds more like a mode in the end to me.

Thomas
Thomas's picture
User offline. Last seen 11 years 44 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-02-06
Posts: 233

omg, that was just an example...
there may be (or maybe not, if dice will be automatic)many more chemes like that.A button just seems better to me, even if this dice is automatic, how will it be guaranteed, that for another example in tournaments not the same player will begin than in round before??? so Tournaments will be more gumble than before, and not who is better or not...!

please add your xfire accountname here:
http://www.hedgewars.org/node/1977

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

OK i just noticed you didn't got my suggestion at all.

My suggestion is:
1) Make it random by default
2) Add a "Game modifier" (under Game Scheme) called "NO TEAM ORDER SCRAMBLE!" or something so that the teams don't get scrambled before the game starts. If people need that option it they just need to activate it!

Besides, we have a "free square" on the modes GUI, it would make it look better. :P

Thomas
Thomas's picture
User offline. Last seen 11 years 44 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-02-06
Posts: 233

Oh, sorry inu didnt read your first post, ok;)

please add your xfire accountname here:
http://www.hedgewars.org/node/1977

rbaleksandar
rbaleksandar's picture
User offline. Last seen 10 years 14 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-01-09
Posts: 685

Better make it with a button. Because how else can you shuffle the teams before the game? For example if the order, which the teams are in, isn't good enough and you want to change it. You can't do this without a button. Smile

HTML = How To Meet the Ladies

Here is my Unofficial Manual for HW. Hope you like it. Wink Smiley Still working on it. Don't worry. Will get it finished...Sometime in the future. Big Grin

Smaxx
Smaxx's picture
User offline. Last seen 13 years 31 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-04-29
Posts: 391

Either its random shuffle or no shuffle. Otherwise you could mix teams yourself as well. Wink Smiley

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

Smaxx allegedly wrote:
Either its random shuffle or no shuffle. Otherwise you could mix teams yourself as well. ;)

I agree, otherwise they'll just keep pressing shuffle until they have the order they want and completely kills the expectation.

Inu allegedly wrote:
My suggestion is:
1) Make it random by default
2) Add a "Game modifier" (under Game Scheme) called "NO TEAM ORDER SCRAMBLE!" or something so that the teams don't get scrambled before the game starts. If people need that option it they just need to activate it!

Please make it happen! Big Grin

rbaleksandar
rbaleksandar's picture
User offline. Last seen 10 years 14 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-01-09
Posts: 685

Smaxx allegedly wrote:

Either its random shuffle or no shuffle. Otherwise you could mix teams yourself as well. Wink Smiley

It is random shuffle, but it's upon request. Mixing teams manually means that you have to remove and add teams in the order you want them. That's ok if you want a strict order. But if you want the order to be random, that can be done only with a button or kind of refresh of the list where each time a random order is displayed. Mixing teams manually is boring (at least for me) especially when you have 5-6 teams and suddenly someone says "Hey, I want to start in the second and not in the fifth round.", which means that you have to remove 4th, 3th and 2nd team, put the new team on place 2, and then add the rest in the list again. Too much work.

The button will allow you to choose from a set of random orders. Let's say player A played as first in game 1, then B,C... In the next game it doesn't matter who will start the game only A mustn't do that. The shuffle button removes the possibility that after shuffling once player A will land on top of the list and start first in the next game, although the others don't want that. So if this happens (it isn't impossible that by random shuffle one thing lands on the same place as before the shuffling), clicking the button will shuffle again.

This is good even for 2-3 teams and shuffling them is a lot faster than doing this manually.

HTML = How To Meet the Ladies

Here is my Unofficial Manual for HW. Hope you like it. Wink Smiley Still working on it. Don't worry. Will get it finished...Sometime in the future. Big Grin

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

You have to look at the downsides too rbaleksandar:
+ People would very often press it more than once to make the order more "convenient" making the other players angry\annoyed
+ It would *completely* ruin the element of surprise when the game starts
+ Harder to implement because it involves messing around with the frontend and fitting 1 more button somewhere
+ Almost all people wont care if that option is not available because most do not ever know the teams are not shuffled by default like in Worms
+ The button to shuffle would only be useful in technically no situations compared to the total of games played daily
+ The team order will still work like it does now, just needs to be activated in the "Modes"

rbaleksandar
rbaleksandar's picture
User offline. Last seen 10 years 14 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-01-09
Posts: 685

Inu allegedly wrote:

You have to look at the downsides too rbaleksandar:
+ People would very often press it more than once to make the order more "convenient" making the other players angry\annoyed

When I see something like that, I tell the room-creator or I leave if he/she doesn't give a toss...
Inu allegedly wrote:

+ It would *completely* ruin the element of surprise when the game starts

Agree here.

Inu allegedly wrote:

+ Harder to implement because it involves messing around with the frontend and fitting 1 more button somewhere

Adding an option in the settings menu is changing the GUI too. Wink Smiley
Inu allegedly wrote:

+ Almost all people wont care if that option is not available because most do not ever know the teams are not shuffled by default like in Worms

Many things remain unknown and unused, because people don't ask and don't care. Wink Smiley
Inu allegedly wrote:

+ The button to shuffle would only be useful in technically no situations compared to the total of games played daily

Depends how you want to play it. Smile
Inu allegedly wrote:

+ The team order will still work like it does now, just needs to be activated in the "Modes"

Can't quite get this one...Explain please. Thanks in advance. Smile

HTML = How To Meet the Ladies

Here is my Unofficial Manual for HW. Hope you like it. Wink Smiley Still working on it. Don't worry. Will get it finished...Sometime in the future. Big Grin

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

.1
Well, thats when the unwanted problems start, and no wants to go through that 'cause of an idiot room creator, and i'm guessing there are gonna be quite a few smart-as*'s now that everyone knows it's not random by default...

.2
Ok, then we both agree. Big Grin

.3
Well, the GUI already has a free slot there, it will make it look nicer

.4
This goes back to .1; give knowledge away but make sure to deal with the consequences and that everyone can't bully anyone else with it :P
Did YOU knew the thing was not shuffled by default before i told you?
Do you now remember a few people "scamming" you with the position some times before?

.5
I want it to be simple and clean, not having to worry if a smart*ss is gonna press a damn button more that once plus ruin the element of surprise.

.6
My suggestion is:
1) Make it random by default
2) Add a "Game modifier" (under Game Scheme) called "NO TEAM ORDER SCRAMBLE!" or something so that the teams don't get scrambled before the game starts. If people need that option it they just need to activate it!

nemo
nemo's picture
User offline. Last seen 22 weeks 3 days ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-01-28
Posts: 1861

Added that modifier in HEAD

--
Oh, what the heck. 1PLXzL1CBUD1kdEWqMrwNUfGrGiirV1WpH <= tip a hedgewars dev

mfuisea
mfuisea's picture
User offline. Last seen 13 years 10 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2010-01-26
Posts: 10

i think it would be great if however the teamlist is, the teams would be randomly orders automaticly every time you start so you can't just press the random button 'til u get the order you want. that way you can never know wich team is goin to start it it would be fair.

Smaxx
Smaxx's picture
User offline. Last seen 13 years 31 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-04-29
Posts: 391

That's the way it's working right now (in dev build): Play order is randomized before the round starts but not in frontend.

Inu
Inu's picture
User offline. Last seen 43 weeks 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-08-26
Posts: 240

Thank you very much for the new function nemo. Smile

rbaleksandar
rbaleksandar's picture
User offline. Last seen 10 years 14 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 2009-01-09
Posts: 685

Thanks. Wink Smiley

HTML = How To Meet the Ladies

Here is my Unofficial Manual for HW. Hope you like it. Wink Smiley Still working on it. Don't worry. Will get it finished...Sometime in the future. Big Grin

User login

Copyright © 2004-2024 Hedgewars Project. All rights reserved. [ contact ]